Frequently Cited Cases, F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal Frequently Cited Cases, F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal

Senos v. Karcz 2014 ONCA 459

The court's decision to adopt this detailed approach reflects a commitment to ensuring a fair and equitable resolution that takes into account the unique circumstances presented in this case. It underscores the importance of a nuanced understanding of the individual's condition, means, needs, and other circumstances in determining support payments, particularly in cases involving recipients of disability support. This is a clear departure from a one-size-fits-all approach, paving the way for a more personalized resolution that better aligns with the realities of the parties involved.

Read More
Frequently Cited Cases, F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal Frequently Cited Cases, F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal

Bak v. Dobell 2007 ONCA 304

The blog is about the 2007 Ontario Court of Appeal case, Bak v. Dobell. The case revolves around complex issues related to child support and the definition of income. The main subject of the case, the respondent, is a financially supported individual whose father provides for him in numerous ways. This includes providing a place to live in, first in a condominium and later in a Stouffville property, and covering various expenses such as medical, psychological, chiropractic, legal, and veterinary bills.

Read More
F - Retroactive Support Jas Dhaliwal F - Retroactive Support Jas Dhaliwal

Family Law Principles that we can learn from Thompson v. Thompson 2013 ONSC 5500 (pleadings)

In cases of child or spousal support predating the start of proceedings, a party must specifically include a claim for retroactive relief in their pleading. This conclusion is based on considerations of certainty, fairness to the payor, and administration of justice. Allowing retroactive claims without specific pleading disrupts the balance between certainty and flexibility, undermines procedural fairness, and creates administrative challenges. The standard form Family Law Application should be amended to include separate headings for retroactive child and spousal support claims. If a litigant fails to plead for retroactive support, they should seek consent to amend their pleading early in the proceeding or request leave to amend before trial.

Read More
Frequently Cited Cases, F - Imputing Income Jas Dhaliwal Frequently Cited Cases, F - Imputing Income Jas Dhaliwal

Family Law Principles that we can learn from Thompson v. Thompson 2013 ONSC 5500 (Imputing Income)

The Thompson v. Thompson case provides a clear exposition of the principles for imputing income, as outlined in Section 19 of Canada's Child Support Guidelines. According to these guidelines, the court may impute income to a spouse based on factors such as intentional under-employment or unemployment, income diversion, unreasonable expense deductions, and more. Essentially, it provides the court with the discretion to ensure a fair child or spousal support outcome based on the spouse's potential earning capability rather than their declared income.

Read More

Family Law Principles that we can learn from Thompson v. Thompson 2013 ONSC 5500 (Retroactive Support Claims)

These claims pertain to support for periods predating the commencement date of the legal pleading in which support is claimed or from the date the legal pleading was commenced to the date that the payor started paying child support. The court expounded upon the Supreme Court of Canada's position on these matters, as laid out in the case D.B.S. v. S.R.G.; L.J.W. v. T.A.R; Henry v. Henry; Hiemstra v. Hiemstra..

Read More
F - Section 7 Expenses Jas Dhaliwal F - Section 7 Expenses Jas Dhaliwal

Child Support Entitlement for Post-Secondary Studies

In the multifaceted world of child support, a recurring question arises concerning the obligation of parents to financially assist their adult children who have chosen to pursue post-secondary education. This is a complex issue, as it is largely contingent on a diverse range of factors that courts take into consideration when making an equitable determination.

Read More
F - Section 7 Expenses Jas Dhaliwal F - Section 7 Expenses Jas Dhaliwal

Section 7 Expenses for Child Support Guidelines (childcare)

In the world of child support, Section 7 expenses hold a significant position. These are also known as 'special or extraordinary expenses' and they can be added to basic child support if they fulfill the criteria of necessity and reasonableness. These costs are usually associated with childcare expenses that occur due to the custodial parent's employment, illness or disability, or training for employment. In this article, we will delve into the intricacies of Section 7 expenses and understand their importance.

Read More
F - Section 7 Expenses Jas Dhaliwal F - Section 7 Expenses Jas Dhaliwal

Health and Medical Expenses in Child Support Cases

In child support cases, health and medical expenses are often considered special or extraordinary expenses. However, the term "extraordinary" might be misleading as these expenses do not necessarily have to be unusual or rare to qualify as an additional payment under section 7 of the Child Support Guidelines. The requirement is that they need to be reasonable and necessary in relation to the child's health and wellbeing.

This provision opens up a broad range of expenses that could potentially be claimed under this section. For instance, dental and vision care costs - including orthodontics and prescription glasses or contact lenses - are among the most commonly claimed health-related expenses. Other eligible costs can include various forms of therapy such as physiotherapy, occupational therapy, and professional counselling. Prescription drugs and specific expenses related to special needs services may also be eligible under section 7.

Read More
F - Section 7 Expenses, F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal F - Section 7 Expenses, F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal

Child Support for Adult Children Pursuing Higher Education

Child support is a subject that often brings to mind images of young children receiving financial assistance from their parents. However, the reality is that adult children, especially those who are still in the process of completing their post-secondary education, may also be in need of financial aid. Despite living independently, these adult children frequently require assistance in covering essential expenses. These expenses encompass tuition fees, costs of textbooks and other study materials, housing costs, meal expenses, and transportation fees, which are collectively referred to as "section 7 expenses".

Read More
F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal

Child Support for Adult Children

The concept of child support extending beyond the age of majority is becoming increasingly common. This can be attributed to several factors such as a child's illness, disability, or continued education. The aim of this article is to provide an in-depth understanding of this issue, focusing on three key aspects: The Divorce Act and its implications, factors considered by courts when deciding on child support for adult children, and the application of the Federal Child Support Guidelines.

Child support is a pivotal issue in family law, drawing even more attention when it relates to adult children. The laws governing this area can often seem complex and confusing, with a multitude of factors coming into play. This blog post aims to elucidate the key aspects of child support law concerning adult children. We will explore the burden of proof, parental control, and quantum of support, providing a comprehensive understanding of this multifaceted subject.

Read More
F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal

Child Support Entitlement and Withdrawal from Parental Control in Family Law

Under the Divorce Act, an adult child who has withdrawn from parental control does not have any entitlement to support. This provision also applies to a child who is 16 or older under the Family Law Act. However, a child who lives with neither parent is not necessarily disentitled to support. The legal position, therefore, is that a child remains financially and emotionally dependent on one or both parents, even if they are not living with either parent. This provision is crucial to understand as it underscores the importance of maintaining a bond with the child, irrespective of the living arrangements.

Read More
F - Child Support, F - Imputing Income Jas Dhaliwal F - Child Support, F - Imputing Income Jas Dhaliwal

The Federal Child Support Guidelines for Self-Employed Individuals

The Federal Child Support Guidelines (SOR/97-175) were established in 1997 to provide certainty in determining child support based on a payor's income and the number of children. However, income determination becomes more complex for self-employed individuals or those earning income through a corporation. This blog post aims to provide an overview of this complex process.

Read More
F - Imputing Income, F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal F - Imputing Income, F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal

Child Support Guidelines: Imputed Income and Its Implications

The Federal Child Support Guidelines provide a comprehensive framework for determining a spouse's annual income for child support purposes. The income is generally determined using sources of income set out under the heading “Total income” in the T1 General form issued by the Canada Revenue Agency. However, the guidelines do not require courts to blindly use the previous year’s total income as reported by the party. The determination can be based on the spouse’s annual income in the past taxation year, the estimated annual income of the current year, or an estimate of probable future income

Read More
F - Child Support, F - Imputing Income Jas Dhaliwal F - Child Support, F - Imputing Income Jas Dhaliwal

Child Support Guidelines in Shared Parenting Cases

In shared parenting arrangements, the Federal Child Support Guidelines stipulate that for Section 9 to be applied, the support payor must be responsible for children at least 40% of the time. This is often a contentious point as the Guidelines do not specify whether the time should be calculated by counting days or hours, which can lead to significant disagreement between parents. If the 40% threshold isn't met, the inquiry ends and the presumptive table amount governs. However, if the threshold is met, the inquiry continues to determine the appropriate amount of support. Understanding the way this threshold is calculated and applied is crucial for parents in shared custody arrangements.

Read More
F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal

Child Support Calculations in Split Parenting Arrangements

In calculating child support for split custody scenarios, the Federal Child Support Guidelines, as per Section 8, stipulates that the payable amount is derived as the set-off between the parties' respective table amounts. This essentially means that the courts calculate the difference between what each parent would have to pay in support based on their individual incomes and the number of children they have custody of. While this section does not provide any direct discretion over the quantum of support, other factors such as section 7 expenses or undue hardship claims may be considered to indirectly adjust the total payable support amount.

Read More
F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal

Child Support: The Importance of Health Insurance Coverage

Section 6 of the Federal Child Support Guidelines empowers the court to order that medical or dental insurance coverage be maintained or acquired for the child. This provision is crucial to ensure that the child's health needs are met, regardless of their parents' marital status. However, the condition is that the coverage should either be available through a spouse's employment or be obtainable at a reasonable rate.

Read More
F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal

Third-Party Custody in Child Support Cases

Child support issues are intricate and multifaceted, particularly when third-party custody comes into play. The standing of third parties to claim child support, the obligation of biological parents to pay, and the allocation of section 7 expenses are key factors that can greatly impact the outcome of these cases.

Read More
F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal

Undue Hardship Claims in Child Support Cases

Undue hardship claims in child support cases can be quite complex. The court's approach to these cases often involves a detailed examination of the circumstances. This post will discuss the concept of undue hardship, the factors considered by the court, and the process of establishing an undue hardship claim.

Read More
F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal F - Child Support Jas Dhaliwal

Lump-Sum Child Support Payments: When and Why They May Be Appropriate

Child support is an essential duty owed by parents to their children, ensuring that their financial needs are met after a divorce or separation. Typically, child support is paid periodically, often in monthly installments. However, there are instances where a lump-sum payment, or a combination of lump-sum and periodic payments, may be allowed. These situations, though, carry the risk of being perceived as a redistribution of wealth rather than a support mechanism.

Read More