The Process and Implications of Setting Aside Waivers in Family Law.
Introduction
The realm of family law is vast and intricate, with numerous nuances that make it a complex field to navigate. One such nuance that often takes precedence is the concept of setting aside waivers, particularly those pertaining to spousal support. Given the potential for significant financial implications, spouses frequently challenge these waivers in the context of marital contracts. The process of setting aside waivers is complex, but understanding it can help mitigate potential future legal disputes and foster a smoother legal process.
Factors Influencing the Setting Aside of Waivers
Waivers of spousal support can be set aside under certain circumstances. These factors play a significant role in determining the legal outcome of such situations.
Lack of Independent Legal Advice: This is one of the most common reasons for setting aside a waiver. If one party has not received independent legal advice, it can lead to an unbalanced agreement favoring one party over the other, making it susceptible to being set aside.
Inadequate Financial Disclosure: Full financial disclosure is a cornerstone of fair and equitable agreements. If full disclosure is not made, or misleading disclosure is provided, the waiver may be set aside.
Duress: If one party was under duress when the agreement was signed, e.g., the agreement was drafted and signed just days before the wedding, it could be grounds for setting aside the waiver.
Poorly Drafted Contract: If the contract itself is drafted inconsistently or inappropriately, it may be deemed invalid, leading to the waiver being set aside.
Absence of Consideration for the Waiver: If there is no consideration or benefit for the waiver, it may also be set aside.
Understanding these factors can assist in avoiding potential pitfalls during the drafting and reviewing process of these clauses.
Procedure for Setting Aside Waivers
The procedure for setting aside a waiver in a separation agreement typically follows the appropriate variation method. This usually involves a fresh Application or a Motion to Change. The moving party, the party who wishes to have the waiver set aside, must justify their reason for doing so. This procedure can be complex and requires a clear understanding of legal processes and the specific circumstances of the agreement. It’s crucial to remember that solid independent legal advice is of paramount importance during this process. Such advice ensures the legitimacy and fairness of the agreement, creating a more solid foundation that is less likely to be successfully challenged in the future.
Statutory Provisions in Family Law
Statutory provisions, as provided by law, play a significant role in the process of setting aside waivers.
The Divorce Act: Section 15.2(4)(c) of the Divorce Act provides the legal framework that allows the court to consider any order, agreement, or arrangement relating to support when making an order for support.
Family Law Act: Similarly, s. 33(4) and s. 56(4) of the Family Law Act allow the court to set aside a provision for support or a waiver in a domestic contract under certain circumstances, such as non-disclosure of significant assets or liabilities or the existence of unconscionable circumstances at the time of the agreement.
These statutory provisions guide the court in its decision-making process, ensuring that the outcome is in line with the established legal principles.
Tips Relating to Setting Aside Waivers
In general, cases decided under these sections suggest the following principles:
Courts should respect the choices of private parties and need a good reason to force them to deviate from their agreements.
Where an agreement is procedurally and substantively sound, it should not be tampered with.
Independent legal advice is of paramount importance.
Where a contract is unconscionable in light of the circumstances that existed at the time of the agreement (Family Law Act, s. 56(4)) or that exist at the time the agreement is being challenged (Family Law Act, s. 33(4)), it should be set aside.
The simple fact that the result of enforcing a contract will differ from the result that would likely have occurred without the contract is not sufficient reason to set aside the agreement.
Even where fraud or non-disclosure can be established, the moving party must establish that prejudice resulted from the fraud before the agreement will be set aside.
Unconscionability as a ground for setting aside a contract includes substantial power imbalances between spouses. Trust and dependence should be considered. Where there is vulnerability or oppression, in the family law context, it may not be necessary to prove unconscionability. The presence of domestic violence will also be a significant factor.
Where one spouse has mental health issues, great care should be taken to ensure that the agreement is fair and that he/she has proper representation.
If the agreement is or can be shown to likely in the future have a negative impact upon the children of the marriage, it will be more likely to be set aside.
As counsel, it is important to both request disclosure, and volunteer disclosure, at the time an agreement is being drafted. Failure to do either may prejudice your client if the opposing party later seeks to have the agreement set aside.
Conclusion
The process of setting aside waivers in family law is a complex one, influenced by various factors and statutory provisions. Understanding these elements and their implications is vital to ensure that the legal agreements drafted are sound, fair, and likely to withstand future challenges. Independent legal advice plays a critical role in this process, guiding parties through the intricate landscape of family law. As such, it is crucial for legal counsel to not only request disclosure but also volunteer it when drafting an agreement. This transparency can greatly mitigate the chances of the agreement being set aside in the future. In conclusion, setting aside waivers is a multifaceted process. By understanding its intricacies, individuals and legal practitioners alike can better navigate this challenging aspect of family law.
THIS BLOG IS FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY AND DOES NOT NECESSARILY REFLECT THE VIEWS OF LAILNA DHALIWAL LLP.
The Content is offered free of charge strictly on an "as is" basis and is intended to provide users with general information only. Lailna Dhaliwal LLP does not warrant or guarantee the accuracy, completeness or fitness of the Content for any particular purpose.
The material provided on the Lailna Dhaliwal LLP/JSDLAW PC website is not intended to provide legal advice or opinions of any kind, and does not constitute legal advice.
No one should act, or refrain from acting, based solely upon the materials provided on this website, without first seeking appropriate legal or other professional advice.
Sending or receiving of these materials does not create a lawyer-client relationship.
Do not provide any confidential information to Lailna Dhaliwal LLP unless and until we have given you a written retainer agreement confirming that we can represent you.