Parenting Jurisdiction in Ontario

Introduction

Parenting disputes can be complex and emotionally charged. One of the critical aspects that add to the complexity is the determination of jurisdiction, that is, which court has the authority to make decisions regarding parenting. According to the Children’s Law Reform Act, Ontario courts can assume jurisdiction in specific circumstances.

Habitual Residence and Physical Presence

The Ontario court can assume jurisdiction if the child is habitually resident in Ontario at the commencement of the parenting application. Habitual residence implies that the child resides in Ontario with both parents, with one parent under a separation agreement or with the consent of the other, or with a person other than a parent on a permanent basis for a significant period of time.

Even if the child is not habitually resident in Ontario, the court can still assume jurisdiction if the child is physically present in Ontario at the start of the application and there is substantial evidence regarding the child's best interests in Ontario. There should not be any pending application for the child's parenting in another place where the child is habitually resident, and no extra-provincial order in respect of custody or access has been recognized by a court in Ontario.

Serious Harm and Parens Patriae Jurisdiction

In situations where the child is physically present in Ontario, and there is a risk of "serious harm" to the child if an order isn't made, the court can take jurisdiction. This is to ensure that the child’s physical and emotional well-being is not compromised and immediate judicial intervention is facilitated.

Another scenario is when the court exercises its parens patriae jurisdiction. This jurisdiction is invoked in situations that are not contemplated by the legislation, for the protection of those who cannot care for themselves, like children. This jurisdiction is particularly relevant when the other jurisdiction is not a signatory to the Hague Convention.

The parens patriae jurisdiction concept originates from the Court of Chancery’s wardship over, initially, mentally incompetent individuals and, later, also children. It is invoked to deal with an uncontemplated situation where it is necessary to do so for the protection of a child.

Declining Jurisdiction

There are also circumstances where an Ontario court may decline jurisdiction. These are usually situations where it is more convenient for another court to exercise jurisdiction, a principle known as Forum Non Conveniens.

For instance, if the majority of the evidence or witnesses are located in another jurisdiction, the Ontario court may find it more suitable to transfer the case to that jurisdiction. However, it is crucial to remember that judges of the Ontario Court of Justice do not have parens patriae jurisdiction.

Conclusion

Understanding jurisdiction in parenting cases is critical as it can significantly impact the outcome of the case. It is always best to consult with a family law expert who can guide you through the complex process. It is also essential to remember that the ultimate goal of any court decision is to uphold the best interests of the child. This goal is at the core of all child custody and access decisions, and the court’s jurisdiction plays a key role in ensuring that the child's best interests are met.

THIS BLOG IS FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY AND DOES NOT NECESSARILY REFLECT THE VIEWS OF LAILNA DHALIWAL LLP.

The Content is offered free of charge strictly on an "as is" basis and is intended to provide users with general information only. Lailna Dhaliwal LLP does not warrant or guarantee the accuracy, completeness or fitness of the Content for any particular purpose.

The material provided on the Lailna Dhaliwal LLP/JSDLAW PC website is not intended to provide legal advice or opinions of any kind, and does not constitute legal advice.

No one should act, or refrain from acting, based solely upon the materials provided on this website, without first seeking appropriate legal or other professional advice.

Sending or receiving of these materials does not create a lawyer-client relationship.

Do not provide any confidential information to Lailna Dhaliwal LLP unless and until we have given you a written retainer agreement confirming that we can represent you.